Attempting All of Costco’s Desserts and Reviewing Them to Discover Greatest Ones

Costco’s 12-inch cheesecake is a staple within the warehouse’s truffles and pies part.

Though $19 is an effective worth for such a giant cheesecake, it is one of the costly objects I bought.

I appreciated that this cheesecake wasn’t dense. As a substitute, it was extremely fluffy with a texture that jogged my memory of a soufflé.

It was so mild that it began to crumble after I pulled a slice onto my plate. The style made up for the messy slice — this cheesecake was tremendous creamy and never overly candy, with a slight tanginess to stability its flavors.

I can not wait to strive it once more with contemporary fruit.

Throughout one purchasing journey, I checked out desserts just some weeks earlier than the Easter vacation.

I discovered a fairly bar cake with layers of carrot cake and cream-cheese frosting, plus a smattering of toasted walnuts on prime.

At $19 for a cake that is nearly 3 kilos, it appeared like an reasonably priced choice to deliver to a vacation gathering.

I really like carrot cake, however I wanted this one had extra taste and moisture within the cake layers.

In my view, they had been fairly dry and tasted a bit bland. I wanted the cake had a extra spiced taste.

For probably the most half, I might solely style the candy, tangy frosting, which was good however a bit of an excessive amount of for the cake.

The banana cream pie was about as huge as the opposite truffles on this part, that are 10 inches, and price $16.

The pie had stability of flavors and textures. The crunchy graham-cracker crust held collectively nicely and added a distinction to all of the creamy layers.

I appreciated that the banana pudding had a pure style, not a man-made one. The caramel on prime added some depth in taste, however it was delicate.

I want there had been extra caramel, and I feel I would slice some contemporary banana on prime for serving subsequent time, however total this was considered one of my favourite Costco desserts.

The chocolate-covered strawberries had been in their very own little cooler towards the entrance of the bakery part, and so they had been marked down from $13 to $6.

On this journey, I went to Costco someday after Mom’s Day, so I assumed these had been leftovers from the vacation.

A few of the strawberries seemed a bit of worse for put on, however I managed to seek out some that did not look previous their prime.

The strawberries chosen for this dessert had been impressively huge, but they had been no match for all the chocolate they had been dipped and drizzled in.

With every chunk, I solely tasted the wealthy, hardened chocolate, regardless of how ripe and juicy the berries had been. I would most likely skip these sooner or later.

Though this dessert was among the many costliest desserts I attempted at $19, it was nicely value that worth primarily based on presentation alone.

It has actually fairly layers of strawberries, cream, and vanilla cake, plus striped white-chocolate decorations on prime.

This cake appears to be a seasonal one which Costco generally brings again in the summertime months.

I wanted this one tasted nearly as good because it seemed. I anticipated it to be candy — it’s dessert, in spite of everything — however this cake was too overly candy to me.

I feel it might’ve had extra balanced flavors if it had rather less strawberry filling and thicker layers of cream.

Just like the strawberries-and-cream cake, the tuxedo cake is a protracted, rectangular layer cake with a fairly design and white-chocolate decorations on prime.

I cherished the look of this $18 cake and thought it was probably the most engaging dessert I bought.

This dessert is extraordinarily wealthy and dense, with chocolate in mousse, ganache, and cake kinds.

There have been fudgy, brownie-like items between the layers of mousse and so they ended up being my favourite a part of the dessert.

I would like extra of the vanilla mousse filling to stability out all the chocolate, and I would most likely serve this with some strawberries for a contemporary component, however it is a tasty and spectacular dessert I might purchase once more.

The chocolate-chunk cookies are a staple within the bakery part of Costco. I bought 24 cookies for simply $10, and I assumed they’d be excellent to select up for a potluck or different gathering.

They seemed nice, too — they appeared smooth with some crispness on the perimeters.

Though I choose baking my very own cookies when my candy tooth strikes, these had been a superb various.

The cookie was smooth with out falling aside, and I appreciated that the chocolate had a powerful, sharp taste to chop by way of the sweetness of the cookie.

Nonetheless, these cookies had been a bit of dry, so if I purchased them once more, I would additionally get milk to serve them with.

Within the bakery part, I noticed a pack of what seemed like six cupcakes, however as soon as I bought nearer, I spotted they had been fairly massive cupcakes or “mini truffles.”

The Mini All-American Muffins are seasonal, and some packs had been accessible throughout my purchasing journey to Costco.

One cake in every pack had a crimson frosting coronary heart. Many of the packs had the crimson frosting caught to the container, however I did discover one bundle with an unblemished frosting coronary heart.

Each mini cake included a beneficiant portion of tremendous fudgy frosting on prime, and the pack of six price $9.

I assumed the tuxedo chocolate-mousse cake was chocolaty, however these mini truffles put that dessert to disgrace when it comes to chocolate taste.

It was so intense and wealthy I might solely take one chunk, and the chocolate taste lingered for a very long time in my mouth.

These mini truffles are greatest shared, and I would want loads of milk to complete even half of 1. Sooner or later, I would skip these and as an alternative seize a full-size chocolate cake.

The ten-inch chocolate cake with chocolate mousse was accessible in a couple of completely different designs — no personalization wanted.

There was a plain possibility, a birthday possibility, and a very cute springtime design with floral frosting decorations, which is what I ended up choosing.

This huge cake, which had mild chopping pointers for 16 slices within the frosting, was $16.

Though the chocolate cake and the mini truffles are related, the chocolate mousse layer within the full-size cake added a much-needed lighter, creamy component to stability out the fudgy icing and wealthy cake.

Due to the added mousse, I would be extra seemingly to purchase this cake once more, although I wasn’t an enormous fan of the mini truffles.

I picked up Costco’s 2-pound lemon-blueberry loaf within the spring.

The loaves seemed unimaginable, with heaps of crumble topping and an icing drizzle throughout. It additionally appeared like deal at $9.

I lower out a slice and was glad to see blueberries towards the highest and center of the loaf — they hadn’t all sunk to the underside.

The loaf itself was mild and spongy with lemon taste, which paired nicely with the chewy blueberries and crunchy crumble topping. I would fortunately purchase this dessert once more, and I would like to strive it warmed with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the facet.

I really like vanilla cake and cheesecake, so I used to be notably intrigued by Costco’s 10-inch white cake crammed with vanilla-cheesecake mousse.

Your complete cake appeared like an important deal, too, at $16. It had a wavy frosting design that might simply be personalised with a message.

This was an on the spot favourite of mine, and I knew instantly I would purchase it once more for any celebrations I’ve arising.

The cake was so mild it jogged my memory of angel-food cake, and the cheesecake was wealthy, a bit of dense, and creamy. The skinny frosting layer on prime was simply the correct amount to maintain the cake from being overly candy.

It will be even higher with contemporary fruit on prime.

I used to be intrigued by this springtime pie, which is crammed with apples, strawberries, and raspberries. It had a lattice crust that seemed completely golden alongside the perimeters, however it was a bit pale within the heart.

At $16, the pie was one of many extra reasonably priced desserts, particularly contemplating how massive it was at practically 5 kilos.

The Kirkland Signature apple-berry pie will definitely fulfill a candy tooth.

I discovered the filling, which was very thick, gooey, and sticky, to be extraordinarily candy. Even simply a few bites of this pie felt overwhelming to me.

The outer components of the crust had been completely crisp and buttery and melted in my mouth. Nonetheless, the paler heart items had been smooth and barely soggy.

I might see items of strawberry and apple within the filling, however the raspberries appeared to have damaged down fully. I additionally seen loads of seeds within the filling; I did not style or really feel them in my bites, however they did not look probably the most appetizing.

Nonetheless, the pie was good, no less than in small portions.

Costco’s basic cheesecake was successful for me, so I had excessive hopes for a tiramisu model of it.

This selection had a easy, however fairly, design with piped whipped cream across the prime and a light-weight dusting of cocoa powder to imitate tiramisu.

This was the most costly dessert I attempted at $24, however it looks as if it might serve a fairly large crowd, given it is 4 ½ kilos.

Costco’s tiramisu cheesecake was actually well worth the worth.

The cheesecake had a crunchy, chocolaty base with a thick layer of coffee-flavored cheesecake and a prime layer of whipped cream.

Its mixture of fluffy whipped cream, wealthy and tangy cheesecake, and crunchy chocolate labored each texturally and flavor-wise.

The one issues that will enhance this cheesecake could be a facet of sliced strawberries and a mug of piping sizzling espresso.

Total, this was considered one of my favourite desserts from Costco.

All in all, I would purchase 9 of those 13 desserts once more.

There is a tie for my favourite between the banana cream pie and the white cake with vanilla-cheesecake mousse. Each the basic and tiramisu cheesecakes are additionally excessive on my listing.

I would skip the chocolate-covered strawberries, strawberries-and-cream bar cake, the carrot bar cake, and the Mini All-American Muffins.

After all, no matter which desserts I would purchase once more, I would be certain to get them after I plan to be with pals or household as a result of most of them had been huge.

This story was initially revealed on June 3, 2024, and most just lately up to date on April 11, 2025.